Love Island USA Season 7 is barely out of the gate, but Huda Mustafa is already acting like she’s in a committed relationship with matching robes and joint couple’s therapy. After coupling up with Jeremiah Brown on night one, Huda’s been moving at lightning speed, dropping declarations about emotional maturity, motherhood, and long-term potential like it’s week four, not day four.
Viewers were initially impressed with her confidence, but the honeymoon phase might already be over. Between dodging red flags and dropping buzzwords like “mom and dad,” things are moving fast, and not necessarily in a good way. And as new Bombshells enter the villa, it’s becoming clear, fans may need to buckle up for this one.
Huda and Jeremiah started strong, but cracks are starting to show…
From the moment Huda and Jeremiah coupled up, she’s treated the connection like it was written in the stars. Their initial chemistry was undeniable. But as the days tick on, the vibe has shifted from promising to… unexpectedly intense.
The turning point came when Huda shared that she has a four-year-old daughter. While that could’ve been a deal-breaker, Jeremiah handled it well. He admitted it might have been an issue for him in past relationships, but with Huda, he said it didn’t change how he felt.
That said, things escalated fast. Huda started talking about their bond like it was unbreakable, calling themselves “mom and dad,” talking about her “emotional maturity,” and basically acting like they’d been together for months, not a few days.
Then came the fresh, flirty Bombshells, who wasted no time turning up the heat with Jeremiah. During a challenge that got a little physical, Huda watched on like she’d just caught him cheating, not like she signed up for a dating show.
Now, instead of a cute early connection, viewers are seeing a relationship that feels way too serious, way too soon. Jeremiah also doesn’t seem quite as locked in, and what once looked promising now feels unbalanced. Now, fans are left scratching their heads.
Love Island fans can’t keep up with Huda’s day 4 intensity
Fans are starting to catch a serious case of the ick when it comes to Huda, and not because she’s not likable, but because her energy feels a little too much for day four.
At first, she came in confident, charismatic, and clearly ready to find a connection. But now, it’s feeling less like romance and more creepy.
Viewers were on board when she and Jeremiah started vibing, but the sudden shift into declarations of “emotional maturity” and calling themselves “mom and dad” is giving people secondhand embarrassment. This is what people are saying,
“do you not see like what me and jeremiah have?” huda….baby this is love island and only day 4 and the girls are bombshells. like girl, be calm #loveislandusa pic.twitter.com/XPjWweT48i
— dai (@vietbaddie) June 7, 2025
Yeah, Huda is giving obsessed. But, hey, Jeremiah is entertaining it. I just hope that Jeremiah doesn’t screw up at Casa cause honestly, she might try to throw herself off of a balcony, and I don’t want my favorite Summer program to be canceled.
— TykiaJ (@TykiaJerry) June 7, 2025
she acting like this is Married at First Sight..she on the wrong show if she can’t handle another islander talking to her “man” pic.twitter.com/cAGxjL3pPT
— phatmammas (@phatneckcoochie) June 7, 2025
and everytimeee someone tries to tell her smth she always gotta use her being a mom as a fucking excuse bro im irked pic.twitter.com/vjbXLA0WCC
— 𓇼 (@bussybows) June 7, 2025
She’s annoying tf outta me I hate when ppl get territorial way too soon plus the way she’s trashing Amaya ..I don’t like that
— kelly (@keooywlld) June 7, 2025
There’s also the way she handles perceived threats. When the Bombshells showed interest in Jeremiah, instead of brushing it off or playing it cool, Huda’s energy turned almost territorial. It wasn’t “I trust our bond,” it was “do you not see what we have?”, like she needed to convince both herself and everyone watching. And that intensity is coming off more possessive than passionate.
Fans are also clocking the performative moments. Constantly narrating her own emotional depth, over-explaining her feelings to Jeremiah, and reacting strongly to even small challenges, it’s giving “trying too hard.”
Ultimately, the ick isn’t about her having feelings, it’s about how heavily she’s leaning into them before they’ve even had time to grow. And Love Island viewers, are pissed!
Love Island USA is currently airing every day, except for Wednesdays, only on Peacock.
This post belongs to FandomWire and first appeared on FandomWire
